damnlines.comdamnlines.comOccupying the historic Chumley's speakeasy space where the culinary term "86" originated, The Eighty Six is chef Michael Vignola's deliberately opaque, guest-list-first West Village steakhouse.
No camera at The Eighty Six yet — these are the closest live lines we cover.
damnlines hasn't pointed a lens at The Eighty Six yet. The most-wanted lines get a camera first.
The Eighty Six, chef Michael Vignola's steakhouse in the former Chumley's speakeasy space, is built to keep its front door opaque. Per Quenelle.ai's guide to getting in, the restaurant runs "guest-list-first" access and is "not listed on Resy or OpenTable"; official reservations release "two weeks in advance on SevenRooms," availability the guest list typically absorbs before it reaches the public.
Walk-ins are the most realistic path for first-timers, but the margin is thin. Quenelle.ai reports the restaurant holds "two to four walk-in spots at the bar each night," occasionally stretching to six at opening, and advises arriving "no later than 4:30 PM" ahead of the 5 PM open. The venue's own site (the86.nyc) confirms the constraint, stating walk-ins "may be accommodated if space allows due to cancellations and no-shows" and recommending guests arrive "promptly at opening."
Quenelle.ai also flags a same-day workaround: occasional DoorDash reservation openings that surface "around 5 PM EST" on the day of the visit, most reliably grabbed by DashPass holders. For repeat visitors, the guide describes a low-key path onto the guest list — asking a server directly, after a meal, "Is there any way you can help me make a reservation for the future?"
Patterns as reported by press and regulars — not measured by damnlines.
Reservations: Guest-list-first and, per Quenelle.ai, "not listed on Resy or OpenTable." Official reservations release roughly two weeks out via SevenRooms and DoorDash, per Quenelle.ai and the venue's own site, with most availability absorbed by the guest list before the public sees it.
Walk-ins: Two to four walk-in bar seats are held nightly (occasionally up to six at opening), per Quenelle.ai; the venue's own site says walk-ins are seated "if space allows due to cancellations and no-shows."
Quenelle.ai reports the restaurant opens at 5 PM and advises walk-in hopefuls arrive "no later than 4:30 PM" to queue for bar seats.
There's no formal line, but the restaurant only holds "two to four walk-in spots at the bar each night" (sometimes up to six), per Quenelle.ai, so arriving late usually means being turned away rather than waiting. Quenelle.ai advises hopefuls "arrive no later than 4:30 PM" for the 5 PM opening, and the venue's own site says walk-ins are seated only "if space allows due to cancellations and no-shows."
Yes, but access is deliberately restricted: per Quenelle.ai, the guest-list steakhouse is "not listed on Resy or OpenTable," with reservations releasing roughly two weeks out via SevenRooms. The venue's own site adds a DoorDash reservation option, though most slots go to the guest list before the public ever sees them, per Quenelle.ai.
Sometimes — Quenelle.ai reports the restaurant holds "two to four walk-in spots at the bar each night," occasionally up to six at opening, making early arrival the best shot for anyone without a reservation or guest-list connection. The venue's own official site adds that walk-ins are accommodated only "if space allows due to cancellations and no-shows."
Yes — per Quenelle.ai, occasional day-of openings appear on DoorDash "around 5 PM EST," and DashPass holders reportedly have the best luck grabbing them. Beyond that, Quenelle.ai says repeat guests can ask their server directly about being added to the guest list for future visits.
Sources: Quenelle — How to Get a Reservation at The Eighty Six NYC · The Eighty Six — Official Site