damnlines.comdamnlines.comA two-location Staten Island pizzeria known for classic New York slices and heroes that draw counter crowds long enough for Yelp reviewers to complain about the wait.
damnlines hasn't pointed a lens at The Pizza Parlor yet. The most-wanted lines get a camera first.
Yelp reviewers of The Pizza Parlor's Huguenot-marketed location (6 Sneden Ave) describe counter waits that outlast a typical pizzeria stop: one review recounts that 45 minutes after placing an order, a crowd had formed at the counter with several customers complaining about the delay, while the counter staff was overheard saying the pizza maker had disappeared for 20 minutes. A separate Yelp review says that 30 minutes after ordering, staff had not yet entered the order into the system at all, with the same complaints resurfacing by the 45-minute mark.
The venue's own site, pizzaparlornyc.com, frames the shop as counter-service only — pickup and delivery are handled through online ordering, and no reservation system is listed for either location. The Infatuation's review of the Huguenot location focuses on the heroes, pasta, and pizza rather than operational details, so the wait-time picture comes almost entirely from Yelp.
The two locations don't carry equal reputations for crowding: the Huguenot-area shop that generated the wait complaints shows 248 reviews on Yelp, while the Westerleigh location at 965 Jewett Avenue shows just 23, with no comparable reports of counter backups, per Yelp's listings for each address.
Patterns as reported by press and regulars — not measured by damnlines.
Reservations: No reservations; counter-service ordering only, per the venue's official site.
Walk-ins: Yes — order-at-the-counter walk-in service at both locations, per the venue's site and Yelp reviewers.
Huguenot location: Sun-Thu 10am-10pm, Fri-Sat 10am-11:30pm; Westerleigh location: Sun-Thu 10am-10pm, Fri-Sat 10am-11pm — per the venue's official site.
Yelp reviewers report waits that build quickly at the counter — one review recounts that 45 minutes after placing an order, a crowd had formed with several customers complaining, while the counter staff said their pizza maker had vanished for 20 minutes. There's no official wait tracker, and the venue's site only supports online ordering for pickup and delivery, so times likely vary by location and order volume.
No — The Pizza Parlor operates as a counter-service pizzeria; its official site (pizzaparlornyc.com) offers online ordering for pickup and delivery only, with no reservation system listed for either the Huguenot or Westerleigh location.
Yes, both locations are walk-in counter service — customers order and pay at the counter, per the venue's online-ordering setup and Yelp reviewers' descriptions of waiting near the register for their food.
The wait complaints described above come from Yelp reviews of the Huguenot-area location at 6 Sneden Avenue; the Westerleigh location at 965 Jewett Avenue has far fewer Yelp reviews and no similarly detailed wait complaints as of this writing.
Sources: Yelp - The Pizza Parlor · The Pizza Parlor official site · The Pizza Parlor - Huguenot location page · The Infatuation - The Pizza Parlor review