The Polo Bar — Line, Wait & How to Get In · Midtown East, NYC

//The line

Per The Infatuation's guide to NYC's toughest restaurant reservations, The Polo Bar does not take reservations online at all — booking happens exclusively by calling a reservationist at (212) 207-8562, with the phone line opening at 10am. The Infatuation reports reservations are released roughly one month in advance on the matching calendar date (e.g., calling on the 30th books a table for the same date the following month), a system it contrasts with the standard same-day Resy drops used at places like Carbone.

The Infatuation is blunt about the odds, writing that calling in "will gently take your hopes out back and bury them six feet under," and describing the restaurant as having "one of the toughest reservations in New York City." For diners shut out of the monthly window, The Infatuation notes calling back around 4pm on the day itself can occasionally surface last-minute cancellations; the outlet does not describe any walk-in line or standby policy at the restaurant.

Reservation-concierge site TablePass adds further context on why the phone line is so hard to crack: it reports that most Polo Bar tables are "allocated to regulars, VIPs, hotel guests, and through direct relationships with the restaurant," with only overflow tables occasionally appearing on Resy — meaning even persistent callers are competing for a small slice of total inventory.

//When the line peaks

Reservation phone line opens at 10am, with dates released roughly one month out on the matching calendar date, per The Infatuation Day-of cancellation calls are best tried around 4pm, per The Infatuation

Patterns as reported by press and regulars — not measured by damnlines.

//Getting in

Reservations: Phone-only: call (212) 207-8562, line opens 10am; reservations released roughly one month out on the matching calendar date, per The Infatuation. Occasional overflow tables may appear on Resy, per TablePass.

Walk-ins: No walk-in line or standby policy is reported; booking runs through the phone reservation system, per The Infatuation.

Official site →

//FAQ

How long is the wait at The Polo Bar?

The Polo Bar doesn't run a walk-in line the way many NYC restaurants do — per The Infatuation, tables are booked exclusively by phone, and the outlet calls it "one of the toughest reservations in New York City." Diners shut out of the monthly booking window can try calling back around 4pm to check for last-minute cancellations, per The Infatuation.

Does The Polo Bar take reservations?

Yes, but only by phone — per The Infatuation, reservations are made by calling (212) 207-8562, with the line opening at 10am and dates released roughly one month in advance on the matching calendar date. TablePass reports that occasional overflow tables can also appear on Resy.

Can you walk into The Polo Bar?

The Infatuation's reporting doesn't describe a walk-in line or standby list at The Polo Bar; access runs through the phone reservation system instead. Same-day openings are possible by calling back around 4pm, per The Infatuation.

Why is it so hard to get a table at The Polo Bar?

Per The Infatuation, the restaurant "does not take reservations online," relying on a phone-only system with a roughly one-month booking window the outlet says will "gently take your hopes out back and bury them six feet under." TablePass adds that many tables go to regulars, VIPs, and hotel guests rather than the general public.

Is there an easier way to get into The Polo Bar?

The Infatuation suggests calling around 4pm on the day you want to dine to check for last-minute cancellations. TablePass also notes that lunch service tends to be easier to book than dinner.