damnlines.comdamnlines.comA West Village slice shop repeatedly ranked among NYC's best pizzerias — Food Network's Best Pizza multiple years, TripAdvisor's #2 NYC pizzeria — known for its Nonna Maria pie.
No camera at Bleecker Street Pizza yet — these are the closest live lines we cover.
damnlines hasn't pointed a lens at Bleecker Street Pizza yet. The most-wanted lines get a camera first.
Want this camera to exist? Tell us on the suggestions page.
Bleecker Street Pizza is a West Village slice shop that has built an outsized reputation relative to its small storefront — named Best Pizza by Food Network multiple years running, ranked the 2nd best pizzeria in NYC by TripAdvisor, and cited by USA Today and the New York Times, largely on the strength of its award-winning Nonna Maria pie.
As a counter-service, walk-up slice shop, waits are managed simply by queuing at the register rather than by reservation. Reported experiences vary widely by time of day — reviewers describe some visits with only a brief ~5-minute wait, and others describe longer lines forming in the early evening (around 7:30pm) that dissipate within about half an hour, so timing your visit outside peak dinner hours may help.
Patterns as reported by press and regulars — not measured by damnlines.
Damnlines doesn't have a live camera at this venue yet, so there's no real-time wait count here. From reported reviews, waits vary a lot by time of day: one visitor described only about a 5-minute wait after ordering during a quieter afternoon, while another reported a longer line around 7:30pm that cleared within about 30 minutes. Expect it to be busiest during evening dinner hours.
It operates primarily as a walk-up, counter-service slice shop, so there's no widely reported formal reservation policy for casual slice orders. It does appear in some online restaurant-booking directories, but the core format is order-at-the-counter.
It's known for its award-winning Nonna Maria pie and has been named Best Pizza by Food Network multiple years running, with TripAdvisor ranking it the 2nd best pizzeria in NYC and mentions from USA Today and the New York Times.
Reported hours are Sunday–Wednesday 10am–2am, Thursday 10am–3am, and Friday–Saturday 10am–5am, though hours can change, so it's worth confirming before a late-night visit.
We don't have live wait data for this venue yet, but reviewer reports suggest early afternoon visits have seen shorter waits (around 5 minutes), while evening hours around 7:30pm have seen longer lines that eased about 30 minutes later.
Sources: Yelp — Bleecker Street Pizza · Yelp search — Bleeker Street Pizza, New York, NY · Time Out New York — Bleecker Street Pizza