damnlines for iPhoneLive lines & push alerts — freeGet
damnlinesdamnlines.com
Watchlist // Chelsea
Brownie bakery stall (inside Chelsea Market) · Chelsea, ManhattanNO. 1056 / 1966

Fat Witch Bakery

A Chelsea Market brownie counter whose dense, fudgy brownies have made it a consistently packed stop for market visitors.

75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011

// Live lines nearby

No camera at Fat Witch Bakery yet — these are the closest live lines we cover.

//Put a camera here

damnlines hasn't pointed a lens at Fat Witch Bakery yet. The most-wanted lines get a camera first.

0
votes
#21 most-wanted in Chelsea
//The line

Yelp reviewers describe the Fat Witch counter at Chelsea Market as "always packed," with customers regularly lining up to buy brownies, per Yelp.

Search results referencing customer feedback note visitors who "waited in line to try this out," and identify December as the bakery's busiest month, when Fat Witch itself advises ordering as early as possible.

//When the line peaks
December holiday season is the bakery's busiest stretch, per Fat Witch's own guidance to order early

Patterns as reported by press and regulars — not measured by damnlines.

//Getting in

Walk-ins: Walk-up counter, no reservations

//FAQ
How long is the wait at Fat Witch Bakery?

No exact wait time is documented, but Yelp reviewers describe the counter as "always packed," with lines forming for brownies, especially during the December holiday rush.

Does Fat Witch Bakery take reservations?

No — it's a walk-up bakery counter with no reservation system.

Can you walk into Fat Witch Bakery?

Yes, it's a walk-in counter, though Yelp reviewers note you may encounter a line at busy times.

Sources: Yelp

Fat Witch Bakery — Line, Wait & How to Get In · Chelsea, NYC | damnlines