damnlines for iPhoneLive lines & push alerts — freeGet
damnlinesdamnlines.com
Watchlist // Kensington
cookie shop · Kensington, BrooklynNO. 1698 / 1966

Pookie Bakery (Big Body Cookies)

A viral cookie counter run by Muhaed Ali inside his family's longtime Kensington gyro restaurant, known for oversized "Big Body Cookies" and 2lb cookie tins.

580 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11218

No camera yet
//Put a camera here

damnlines hasn't pointed a lens at Pookie Bakery (Big Body Cookies) yet. The most-wanted lines get a camera first.

0
votes
#3 most-wanted in Kensington
//The line

News 12 Brooklyn reports Pookie's cookie counter, hidden inside a longtime Kensington gyro spot, "became a viral sensation" after videos of its dessert tins racked up millions of views, drawing customers from across the tristate area and beyond (News 12 Brooklyn). Owner Muhaed Ali now produces 1,500 to 2,000 cookies a day to keep up.

Demand is heavy enough that shoppers report roughly 30-minute waits for the signature cookie tins, and the 2lb tins can sell out earlier in the day, so customers are advised to arrive early or call ahead (Yelp).

//When the line peaks
Cookie tins can sell out earlier in the day, per Yelp customer reports Evening hours draw waits given the shop stays open until 1am daily

Patterns as reported by press and regulars — not measured by damnlines.

//Getting in

Walk-ins: Walk-in counter inside gyro restaurant

Open until 1am daily, per News 12 Brooklyn

Official site →

//FAQ
How long is the wait at Pookie Bakery?

Customers report roughly a 30-minute wait for cookie tins during busy periods, per Yelp reviews, and the 2lb tins can sell out before end of day.

Does Pookie Bakery take reservations?

No reservation system is described; it's a walk-up counter, though customers are advised to call ahead if a specific tin size is wanted (Yelp).

Can you walk into Pookie Bakery?

Yes, it's a walk-in counter inside the family's gyro restaurant, open until 1am daily, though popular tins can run out earlier (News 12 Brooklyn).

Sources: News 12 Brooklyn - Road Trip: Pookie's Cookies in Kensington · Yelp - Pookie

Pookie Bakery (Big Body Cookies) — Line, Wait & How to Get In · Kensington, NYC | damnlines